 Pastors' Wives by Lisa Cullen Plume April 30, 2013; 368 Pages What’s it like when the man you married is already married to God? asks Pastors’ Wives, an often surprising yet always emotionally true first novel set in a world most of us know only from the outside. Lisa Takeuchi Cullen’s debut novel Pastors’ Wives follows three women whose lives converge and intertwine at a Southern evangelical megachurch. Ruthie follows her Wall Street husband from New York to Magnolia, a fictional suburb of Atlanta, when he hears a calling to serve at a megachurch called Greenleaf. Reeling from the death of her mother, Ruthie suffers a crisis of faith—in God, in her marriage, and in herself. Candace is Greenleaf’s “First Lady,” a force of nature who’ll stop at nothing to protect her church and her superstar husband. Ginger, married to Candace’s son, struggles to play dutiful wife and mother while burying her calamitous past. All their roads collide in one chaotic event that exposes their true selves. Inspired by Cullen’s reporting as a staff writer for Time magazine, Pastors’ Wives is a dramatic portrayal of the private lives of pastors’ wives, caught between the demands of faith, marriage, duty, and love. (from Amazon). I'm sure you've had this happen: you read the description on the back of the book and think... Maybe. Maybe this will be good. Maybe I'll like it. Then again, maybe I won't. Book Indifference. Then something about it tips the scale and you decide to give it a try. It might be the cover art or perhaps a recommendation from a trusted friend or librarian. For me it was winning a free advance copy from LibraryThing. As I sat down with my copy of Pastors' Wives I re-read the cover. My christian sensibility expressed momentary trepidation as I wondered if I might be offended by any of the content. Usually my religious beliefs don't play a big part in my reading, but this seemed like it might hit close to home. I decided that if it got too uncomfortable I just wouldn't finish. After all that's always our prerogative. As it turns out there was nothing to worry about. And in fact my indifference quickly turned to interest as I became infatuated with the women of Greenleaf. Ruthie, Candace and Ginger have nothing in common - except Greenleaf. The colossal megachurch ("Is that the mall?" asks Ruthie the first time she sees it) that for very different reasons is the nucleus that their lives revolve around. Each woman has a story, and they are as unique as their personalities. The book is written by alternating between these three characters. The author does a terrific job of giving them all a voice, and giving us the opportunity to really get to know them (something that doesn't always happen with this style). In addition to the women (and their men), Greenleaf is a predominate character. I've seen these megachurches on TV, and I always wondered what they're like. Even though this one isn't real I get the impression that Ms. Cullen's portrayal is pretty accurate. It's something to see how influential it is on the characters. Everything from their homes, the cars they drive and the clothes they wear to people they befriend is orchestrated by the church. Ms. Cullen's writing has a natural swiftness to it that swept me in right from the beginning. If I would have been able to I probably would have read it in one sitting. As it turns out it only took a couple of days. There's humor and sadness, and several unexpected events that continued to pique my interest as I followed these women. It seems that each of them is on a journey to discover things about themselves, their relationship with their spouse, their relationship with each other and their relationship with God. There are lots of references to the scripture that I found appropriate and necessary to the book (after all it is about pastors' wives!). I really enjoyed this book, and I think that it will appeal to a wide audience. There were times that I found myself laughing out loud and on two separate occasions reading through tears. That's unusual for me. Not being emotional, but actually crying! That reason alone makes it worthy of a recommendation. The truth is though that Pastor's Wives has a lot more than that going for it. So, if you find yourself feeling indifferent, I hope that my review will be the thing that encourages you to give it a try. I really think you're going to like it! To learn more about Lisa Cullen visit her website. Just like her writing in the book, the site is smart, interesting and funny. There's a great article on why she wrote Pastors' Wives, and another on picking names for the characters. You can also connect with her on Facebook.  Thanks so much for stopping by and sharing part of your day with me.
One of the great things about books is we all respond to them differently. Everyone has an opinion and there is no right or wrong. I'd love to hear what you thought of this book, and invite you to share your views in the comment section. Wishing you all the happiness words can bring! Robin B. Click to: read more Book Reviews; go to the Athol Public Library; or visit Crochet Nirvana!
1 Comment
 What a Mother Knows by Leslie Lehr Sourcebooks Landmark May 7, 2013; 317 pages How Far Will a Mother Go to Find Her Daughter? Michelle Mason can't remember that day, that drive, that horrible crash that killed the young man in her car. All she knows is she's being held responsible, and her daughter is missing. Despite a shaky marriage, a threatening lawsuit, and troubling flashbacks pressing in on her, Michelle throws herself into searching. Her daughter in the one person who might know what really happened that day, but the deeper Michelle digs, the more she questions the innocence of those closest to her, even herself. As her search hurtles toward a shattering revelation, Michelle must face the biggest challenge of her life. (from Amazon) Before we get started I'd like to welcome you to kick-off post in the blog tour. I've been reviewing books and sharing them on the web for a while now, but this is my first time as part of a tour. Talk about pressure! Anyway, I'm glad you're here and that I have the chance to tell you what I think about this book. We meet the main character Michelle 18 months after being involved in a horrific accident. From the cover we know that Michelle was driving, a young man died, she's being blamed, and her daughter is missing. Unfortunately Michelle doesn't know any of these things. Her recovery has been long and difficult. The traumatic brain injury she sustained has left her without any memory of the crash or the events leading up to it. Her husband Drew decided that it would be better to keep the truth from her so she doesn't get upset. He fabricates a story that Nikki, their teenage daughter, is attending school in Australia and even mails her postcards of famous landmarks. Now that Michelle has been released from the hospital she believes that Nikki will be coming home too. Her joyous homecoming turns surreal as the facts about the accident are revealed. In addition she learns that Drew is returning to New York where he has been living (and working). Holy cow! Talk about upsetting and stressful! Michelle is stunned and angry. How could this happen? Why didn't anyone tell her? Where is her daughter and why isn't anyone doing anything to find her? These are some of the questions that she is determined to answer. But how? The last thing she remembers is wrapping Nikki's sweet 16 birthday present - when everything was normal. Or was it? Slowly Michelle begins to piece together the fractured bits of her memory as she struggles to find out what happened to her daughter. I like Michelle, but I don't like her husband. I understand that sometimes you want to avoid giving people difficult news, but I can't believe for an instant that he was able to convince the doctors, hospital and therapists to go along with his lie about Nikki. It also seems incredibly harsh that he left her after less than 24 hours of being out of the hospital. Apparently their marriage was suffering more than anyone let on, but I guess that doesn't surprise me considering the lack of compassion he shows. I can't help but think that this book would make terrific Lifetime Movie. It's got all the elements that you expect. A little tragedy, family drama, the mystery of the missing daughter, and the strained relationship between Michelle and her mother. Then there's the Hollywood backdrop and the untimely death of a rising star. All of those things feel a little cliche, but that doesn't mean that it's not a good story. I moved quickly through the book, rooting for Michelle and cursing the people who hindered her progress. The author captures the sense of urgency and desperation that any mother would surely feel in Michelle's situation. As a knitter I was thrilled to see that there are several references to yarn and knitting! It's something Michelle and Nikki share and the appearance of a unique yarn or garment has special meaning to both of them. I also like the classic rock references and the lyrics that Nikki used to send messages and share her feelings. More than once I found myself with a Door's song stuck in my head long after I closed the book! What a Mother Knows is an intriguing story that really made me think. How far would I go to find my child? That's easy - as far as I have to. How about you? What a Mother Knows - Book Launch / Blog Tour |
| April 29 – Robin Reads & Writes May 1 - Chick Lit is Not Dead May 2 - Bookfoolery May 3 - The Bookworm May 4 - Lori's Reading Corner May 5 - The Self Taught Cook May 6 - Mrs Condit Reads Books May 7 - From the TBR Pile May 8 - Cocktails and Books May 9 - Burton Book Review May 10 - Chick Lit Plus May 12 - The Book Diva’s Reads May 13 - Peeking Between the Pages May 14 - Long and Short Reviews | May 15 - Rainy Day Ramblings May 16 - Help4NewMoms May 17 - Winey Mommy May 18 - Cozy Up with a Good Read May 20 - A Bookish Way of Life May 21 – Confessions of a Book Junkie May 22 - 5 Minutes for Mom May 23 - Angela Klocke May 24 - WeeShare May 26 - Brianna Lee May 28 - Reviewing Shelf May 29 - Socrates Book Reviews May 31 - Passionate about Books |
| | Coming Events There are two opportunities to talk with Leslie! She and Hope Edelman (author of the bestselling book Motherless Daughters) will be hosting a live chat on BookTalk Nation on May 1st. And, Leslie is taking questions on Goodreads. Visit Leslie's website for a complete list of appearances and events. |
Thanks so much for stopping by and sharing part of your day with me.
One of the great things about books is we all respond to them differently. Everyone has an opinion and there is no right or wrong. I'd love to hear what you thought of this book, and invite you to share your views in the comment section.
Wishing you all the happiness words can bring!
Robin B.
Click to:
read more Book Reviews;
go to the Athol Public Library; or
visit Crochet Nirvana!
Greetings fellow reading enthusiasts!
How nice of you to stop by. Today I find myself with a bit of a dilemma. Nothing too dramatic, it's just that I've got a rather large pile of books that are waiting to be reviewed. I've already done the reading, and jotted my impressions along with the occasional quote in my handy-dandy notebook. I just haven't made the time to do the writing. I love it, but it takes me a while to get the words from the inside to the outside in a way that makes sense to other people. I also know that if I lollygag for too long I'll forget what the book was really about and the review will never get written. Instead of letting that happen I came up with a solution - mini reviews. A brief, scaled down version that lets you know a little about the book and a little about what I think. All of these books (except one) were published within the last year and should be available at your local library - that's where mine came from! There's a variety of different genres, with something for most everyone. I hope that you enjoy the abridged reviews and are inspired to visit the library and check out the latest titles in popular fiction.
How nice of you to stop by. Today I find myself with a bit of a dilemma. Nothing too dramatic, it's just that I've got a rather large pile of books that are waiting to be reviewed. I've already done the reading, and jotted my impressions along with the occasional quote in my handy-dandy notebook. I just haven't made the time to do the writing. I love it, but it takes me a while to get the words from the inside to the outside in a way that makes sense to other people. I also know that if I lollygag for too long I'll forget what the book was really about and the review will never get written. Instead of letting that happen I came up with a solution - mini reviews. A brief, scaled down version that lets you know a little about the book and a little about what I think. All of these books (except one) were published within the last year and should be available at your local library - that's where mine came from! There's a variety of different genres, with something for most everyone. I hope that you enjoy the abridged reviews and are inspired to visit the library and check out the latest titles in popular fiction.
The Burning Air by Erin Kelly
Feb 21, 2013
Pamela Dorman Books; 336 Pages
The MacBrides lead a cozy life of upper class privilege: good looks (more or less), a beautiful home, tuition-free education at the prestigious private school where Rowan is headmaster, an altruistic righteousness inherited from magistrate Lydia.
But when Rowan and his three grown children gather for the first time since Lydia’s passing at the family’s weekend home—a restored barn in the English countryside—years of secrets surface, and they discover a stranger in their midst. A stranger who is convinced that Lydia was a murderer. A stranger who has been exacting vengeance upon the family for years without their ever knowing. And one who will threaten the youngest MacBride, baby Edie, and the clan’s memory of Lydia, shattering their world forever.
Oh, this is a good one! Different from what I've been reading lately and a welcome change. It appears that the MacBrides have it all, but like so many families there are skeletons and secrets lying just beneath the surface of their seemingly perfect world. With vivid detail the author brought each member to life and I enjoyed the way that growing up in the same house had such a varied impact on each person. There is a darkness that shadows them all, but the most disturbing is the stranger. A psychologically complex and frightening character whose adult life is shaped by a chaotic childhood and a series of unexpected events. This is a page turner that kept me in suspense to the very end.
Feb 21, 2013
Pamela Dorman Books; 336 Pages
The MacBrides lead a cozy life of upper class privilege: good looks (more or less), a beautiful home, tuition-free education at the prestigious private school where Rowan is headmaster, an altruistic righteousness inherited from magistrate Lydia.
But when Rowan and his three grown children gather for the first time since Lydia’s passing at the family’s weekend home—a restored barn in the English countryside—years of secrets surface, and they discover a stranger in their midst. A stranger who is convinced that Lydia was a murderer. A stranger who has been exacting vengeance upon the family for years without their ever knowing. And one who will threaten the youngest MacBride, baby Edie, and the clan’s memory of Lydia, shattering their world forever.
Oh, this is a good one! Different from what I've been reading lately and a welcome change. It appears that the MacBrides have it all, but like so many families there are skeletons and secrets lying just beneath the surface of their seemingly perfect world. With vivid detail the author brought each member to life and I enjoyed the way that growing up in the same house had such a varied impact on each person. There is a darkness that shadows them all, but the most disturbing is the stranger. A psychologically complex and frightening character whose adult life is shaped by a chaotic childhood and a series of unexpected events. This is a page turner that kept me in suspense to the very end.
Ashfall (Ashfall Trilogy - Book 1) by Mike Mullen
Ashen Winter (Book 2)
Both Published October 16, 2012
Tanglewood Press; 476 Pages
Under the bubbling hot springs and geysers of Yellowstone National Park is a supervolcano. Most people don't know it's there. The caldera is so large that it can only be seen from a plane or satellite. It just could be overdue for an eruption, which would change the landscape and climate of our planet.
For Alex, being left alone for the weekend means having the freedom to play computer games and hang out with his friends without hassle from his mother. Then the Yellowstone supervolcano erupts, plunging his hometown into a nightmare of darkness, ash, and violence. Alex begins a harrowing trek to search for his family and finds help in Darla, a travel partner he meets along the way. Together they must find the strength and skills to survive and outlast an epic disaster.
What can I say - I loved the first two books in this trilogy. I'm not even sure why I picked the first one up since they're way outside of my normal reading zone. Anyway, I was pulled in from the very start. The author wastes no time getting to the action and by page 5 the world is changed forever. This is a fast moving, in your face, high octane story where all kinds of intense things happen. Alex is a smart kid, and soon learns that he is responsible for his survival. With every decision he makes he is faced with a whole new set of circumstances that require another decision. Can you imagine? I found myself reading late into the night, finishing the first book in a few days. Luckily for me book two was available, and I moved through it just as fast! These books are more than just a thrill ride. They show the importance of family. They raise questions about morals and humanity and compassion when the world we know no longer exists. They made me think about how fragile life is and what I would do to protect myself and the ones I love. I could say more, but I'll end with this: I enjoyed the series so far and I'm anxious to see what happens next!
Ashen Winter (Book 2)
Both Published October 16, 2012
Tanglewood Press; 476 Pages
Under the bubbling hot springs and geysers of Yellowstone National Park is a supervolcano. Most people don't know it's there. The caldera is so large that it can only be seen from a plane or satellite. It just could be overdue for an eruption, which would change the landscape and climate of our planet.
For Alex, being left alone for the weekend means having the freedom to play computer games and hang out with his friends without hassle from his mother. Then the Yellowstone supervolcano erupts, plunging his hometown into a nightmare of darkness, ash, and violence. Alex begins a harrowing trek to search for his family and finds help in Darla, a travel partner he meets along the way. Together they must find the strength and skills to survive and outlast an epic disaster.
What can I say - I loved the first two books in this trilogy. I'm not even sure why I picked the first one up since they're way outside of my normal reading zone. Anyway, I was pulled in from the very start. The author wastes no time getting to the action and by page 5 the world is changed forever. This is a fast moving, in your face, high octane story where all kinds of intense things happen. Alex is a smart kid, and soon learns that he is responsible for his survival. With every decision he makes he is faced with a whole new set of circumstances that require another decision. Can you imagine? I found myself reading late into the night, finishing the first book in a few days. Luckily for me book two was available, and I moved through it just as fast! These books are more than just a thrill ride. They show the importance of family. They raise questions about morals and humanity and compassion when the world we know no longer exists. They made me think about how fragile life is and what I would do to protect myself and the ones I love. I could say more, but I'll end with this: I enjoyed the series so far and I'm anxious to see what happens next!
The Husband List by Janet Evanovich & Dorien Kelly
January 8, 2013
St. Martin's Press; 320 Pages
Caroline Maxwell would like nothing more than to join her brother, Eddie, and his friend, Jack Culhane, on their adventures. While Jack and Eddie are off seeing the world, buying up businesses and building wildly successful careers, Caroline's stuck at home frightening off the men her mother hopes will ask for her hand in marriage. When her mother sets her sights on the questionable Lord Bremerton as a possible suitor, Caroline struggles with her instincts and the true nature of her heart. She longs for adventure, passion, love, and most of all . . . Jack Culhane, an unconventional Irish-American bachelor with new money and no title. A completely unacceptable suitor in the eyes of Caroline's mother. But Caroline's dark hair, brilliant eyes and quick wit have Jack understanding just why it is people fall in love and get married.
If you read my review of Janet's last book, you know that I'm a long time fan who has become disappointed in the (lack of) development of her main character Stephanie Plum. Thankfully, this is not a Stephanie Plum mystery. The Husband List is something very different. It's a historical romantic comedy that is reminiscent of old school Evanovich. It's witty and warm, quick and engaging. The story line is simple and it's predictable but that doesn't stop it from being a relaxing way to spend your reading time. I enjoyed the humor and adventure that the main character Caroline brings to the ordinary events of the time period. If you're looking for something light and entertaining this is good pick.
January 8, 2013
St. Martin's Press; 320 Pages
Caroline Maxwell would like nothing more than to join her brother, Eddie, and his friend, Jack Culhane, on their adventures. While Jack and Eddie are off seeing the world, buying up businesses and building wildly successful careers, Caroline's stuck at home frightening off the men her mother hopes will ask for her hand in marriage. When her mother sets her sights on the questionable Lord Bremerton as a possible suitor, Caroline struggles with her instincts and the true nature of her heart. She longs for adventure, passion, love, and most of all . . . Jack Culhane, an unconventional Irish-American bachelor with new money and no title. A completely unacceptable suitor in the eyes of Caroline's mother. But Caroline's dark hair, brilliant eyes and quick wit have Jack understanding just why it is people fall in love and get married.
If you read my review of Janet's last book, you know that I'm a long time fan who has become disappointed in the (lack of) development of her main character Stephanie Plum. Thankfully, this is not a Stephanie Plum mystery. The Husband List is something very different. It's a historical romantic comedy that is reminiscent of old school Evanovich. It's witty and warm, quick and engaging. The story line is simple and it's predictable but that doesn't stop it from being a relaxing way to spend your reading time. I enjoyed the humor and adventure that the main character Caroline brings to the ordinary events of the time period. If you're looking for something light and entertaining this is good pick.
Red Velvet Cupcake Murder (A Hannah Swenson Mystery - #17) by Joanne Fluke
February 26, 2013
Kensington; 304 Pages
On a hot, muggy evening, the last thing Hannah Swensen wants to do is squeeze into pantyhose for the Grand Opening of the refurbished Albion Hotel. But with her famous Red Velvet cupcakes being served in the hotel's new Red Velvet lounge, she can't back out. The party starts off with a bang with the unexpected arrival of Doctor Bev on the arm of a wealthy investor -- and comes to a screeching halt when a partygoer takes a dive off the rooftop garden.
I'm a fan of the Hannah Swensen mysteries. I call them "Mystery-Lite" I like to listen to them on CD in my kitchen while I'm cooking. Hannah likes to cook and she likes to bake delicious confections for her store - The Cookie Jar. She also likes to eat - and I do too! That's about where our similarities end. Hannah has a penchant for finding dead bodies, and for solving the mysteries that surround them. I've read or listened to most of the 17 books in the series and still find that I enjoy them. (I'm not sure why I have more tolerance for Hannah than I do for Stephanie (Plum) - that's something to explore another day!) As for this book, it delivers everything that I've come to expect. There's nothing too graphic and plenty of kind and supportive family and friends ready to lend a hand. The mystery itself wasn't much of a surprise, but that's okay. I don't think these books are for everyone, but if you like murder among friendly folks (think the Faith Fairchild Mysteries or the Puzzle Lady books) than you'll enjoy this one.
February 26, 2013
Kensington; 304 Pages
On a hot, muggy evening, the last thing Hannah Swensen wants to do is squeeze into pantyhose for the Grand Opening of the refurbished Albion Hotel. But with her famous Red Velvet cupcakes being served in the hotel's new Red Velvet lounge, she can't back out. The party starts off with a bang with the unexpected arrival of Doctor Bev on the arm of a wealthy investor -- and comes to a screeching halt when a partygoer takes a dive off the rooftop garden.
I'm a fan of the Hannah Swensen mysteries. I call them "Mystery-Lite" I like to listen to them on CD in my kitchen while I'm cooking. Hannah likes to cook and she likes to bake delicious confections for her store - The Cookie Jar. She also likes to eat - and I do too! That's about where our similarities end. Hannah has a penchant for finding dead bodies, and for solving the mysteries that surround them. I've read or listened to most of the 17 books in the series and still find that I enjoy them. (I'm not sure why I have more tolerance for Hannah than I do for Stephanie (Plum) - that's something to explore another day!) As for this book, it delivers everything that I've come to expect. There's nothing too graphic and plenty of kind and supportive family and friends ready to lend a hand. The mystery itself wasn't much of a surprise, but that's okay. I don't think these books are for everyone, but if you like murder among friendly folks (think the Faith Fairchild Mysteries or the Puzzle Lady books) than you'll enjoy this one.
The Causal Vacancy by J.K. Rowling
September 27, 2012
Little, Brown & Co.; 512 Pages
When Barry Fairbrother dies unexpectedly in his early forties, the little town of Pagford is left in shock. Pagford is, seemingly, an English idyll, with a cobbled market square and an ancient abbey, but what lies behind the pretty façade is a town at war. Rich at war with poor, teenagers at war with their parents, wives at war with their husbands, teachers at war with their pupils…. Pagford is not what it first seems. And the empty seat left by Barry on the town’s council soon becomes the catalyst for the biggest war the town has yet seen. Who will triumph in an election fraught with passion, duplicity and unexpected revelations? Blackly comic, thought-provoking and constantly surprising, The Casual Vacancy is J.K. Rowling’s first novel for adults.
Alright folks. I'm at a loss here. The truth is I just couldn't get into it, and after about 100 pages or so I gave up. I wanted to love it. Of course I realize that it had to be very different from Harry Potter, and that's fine because usually I don't read books about young wizards. But Rowling is a truly gifted story teller and that's what I was looking for. Sadly, I never found it. The main reason that it failed me is because I was introduced to so many members of the community in short little snippets that I lost track and then I lost interest. I thought that eventually it would blend together into a cohesive story line, and perhaps it does. It just didn't happen quickly enough for me. I read several reviews on LibraryThing that eluded to many sharing my feelings. However there also was a rather large contingency that said if you can endure the first half of the book you will be rewarded for your diligence in the second half. I suppose that's a good thing, but I'd rather read a book that's good all the way through instead!
September 27, 2012
Little, Brown & Co.; 512 Pages
When Barry Fairbrother dies unexpectedly in his early forties, the little town of Pagford is left in shock. Pagford is, seemingly, an English idyll, with a cobbled market square and an ancient abbey, but what lies behind the pretty façade is a town at war. Rich at war with poor, teenagers at war with their parents, wives at war with their husbands, teachers at war with their pupils…. Pagford is not what it first seems. And the empty seat left by Barry on the town’s council soon becomes the catalyst for the biggest war the town has yet seen. Who will triumph in an election fraught with passion, duplicity and unexpected revelations? Blackly comic, thought-provoking and constantly surprising, The Casual Vacancy is J.K. Rowling’s first novel for adults.
Alright folks. I'm at a loss here. The truth is I just couldn't get into it, and after about 100 pages or so I gave up. I wanted to love it. Of course I realize that it had to be very different from Harry Potter, and that's fine because usually I don't read books about young wizards. But Rowling is a truly gifted story teller and that's what I was looking for. Sadly, I never found it. The main reason that it failed me is because I was introduced to so many members of the community in short little snippets that I lost track and then I lost interest. I thought that eventually it would blend together into a cohesive story line, and perhaps it does. It just didn't happen quickly enough for me. I read several reviews on LibraryThing that eluded to many sharing my feelings. However there also was a rather large contingency that said if you can endure the first half of the book you will be rewarded for your diligence in the second half. I suppose that's a good thing, but I'd rather read a book that's good all the way through instead!
The Devil in the White City by Erik Larson
February 11, 2003
Crown; 464 Pages
Two men, each handsome and unusually adept at his chosen work, embodied an element of the great dynamic that characterized America’s rush toward the twentieth century. The architect was Daniel Hudson Burnham, the fair’s brilliant director of works and the builder of many of the country’s most important structures, including the Flatiron Building in New York and Union Station in Washington, D.C. The murderer was Henry H. Holmes, a young doctor who, in a malign parody of the White City, built his “World’s Fair Hotel” just west of the fairgrounds—a torture palace complete with dissection table, gas chamber, and 3,000-degree crematorium. Burnham overcame tremendous obstacles and tragedies as he organized the talents of Frederick Law Olmsted, Charles McKim, Louis Sullivan, and others to transform swampy Jackson Park into the White City, while Holmes used the attraction of the great fair and his own satanic charms to lure scores of young women to their deaths. What makes the story all the more chilling is that Holmes really lived, walking the grounds of that dream city by the lake.
Chilling, terrifying, intense, unimaginable... These are a few words that come to mind as I think about this book. It's a complete departure from what I've been reading lately. Actually, I listened to this one on the recommendation of a library friend/patron. And as disturbing as it was, I think it's safe to say that both of us were captivated by this story. It felt like equal parts of fascination and horror. It was interesting to learn about the history of the Chicago World's Fair from the perspective of those that were responsible for bringing it to life. Yet in the same moment that something bright and beautiful was being created, the Doctor was casting an evil shadow over the city that he viewed as his personal macabre playground. Although this book was published a decade ago, it is a timeless tale of good and evil. It has some gruesome scenes and images that may not be for everyone - Mystery-Lite this story is not!
February 11, 2003
Crown; 464 Pages
Two men, each handsome and unusually adept at his chosen work, embodied an element of the great dynamic that characterized America’s rush toward the twentieth century. The architect was Daniel Hudson Burnham, the fair’s brilliant director of works and the builder of many of the country’s most important structures, including the Flatiron Building in New York and Union Station in Washington, D.C. The murderer was Henry H. Holmes, a young doctor who, in a malign parody of the White City, built his “World’s Fair Hotel” just west of the fairgrounds—a torture palace complete with dissection table, gas chamber, and 3,000-degree crematorium. Burnham overcame tremendous obstacles and tragedies as he organized the talents of Frederick Law Olmsted, Charles McKim, Louis Sullivan, and others to transform swampy Jackson Park into the White City, while Holmes used the attraction of the great fair and his own satanic charms to lure scores of young women to their deaths. What makes the story all the more chilling is that Holmes really lived, walking the grounds of that dream city by the lake.
Chilling, terrifying, intense, unimaginable... These are a few words that come to mind as I think about this book. It's a complete departure from what I've been reading lately. Actually, I listened to this one on the recommendation of a library friend/patron. And as disturbing as it was, I think it's safe to say that both of us were captivated by this story. It felt like equal parts of fascination and horror. It was interesting to learn about the history of the Chicago World's Fair from the perspective of those that were responsible for bringing it to life. Yet in the same moment that something bright and beautiful was being created, the Doctor was casting an evil shadow over the city that he viewed as his personal macabre playground. Although this book was published a decade ago, it is a timeless tale of good and evil. It has some gruesome scenes and images that may not be for everyone - Mystery-Lite this story is not!
Thanks so much for stopping by and sharing part of your day with me.
One of the great things about books is we all respond to them differently. Everyone has an opinion and there is no right or wrong. I hope that you enjoyed my mini-reviews. I feel so much better now that they're done! Have you read any of these yet? I'd love to hear your thoughts on any of the titles.
Until next time,
Wishing you all the happiness words can bring!
Robin B.
Click to:
read more Book Reviews;
go to the Athol Public Library; or
visit Crochet Nirvana!
One of the great things about books is we all respond to them differently. Everyone has an opinion and there is no right or wrong. I hope that you enjoyed my mini-reviews. I feel so much better now that they're done! Have you read any of these yet? I'd love to hear your thoughts on any of the titles.
Until next time,
Wishing you all the happiness words can bring!
Robin B.
Click to:
read more Book Reviews;
go to the Athol Public Library; or
visit Crochet Nirvana!
Habits of the House by Fay Weldon
St. Martin's Press
January 15, 2013; 320 Pages
From the award-winning novelist and writer of Upstairs Downstairs, the launch of a brilliant new trilogy about what life was really like for masters and servants before the world of Downton Abbey.
As the Season of 1899 comes to an end, the world is poised on the brink of profound, irrevocable change. The Earl of Dilberne is facing serious financial concerns. The ripple effects spread to everyone in the household: Lord Robert, who has gambled unwisely on the stock market and seeks a place in the Cabinet; his unmarried children, Arthur, who keeps a courtesan, and Rosina, who keeps a parrot in her bedroom; Lord Robert’s wife Isobel, who orders the affairs of the household in Belgrave Square; and Grace, the lady’s maid who orders the life of her mistress.
Lord Robert can see no financial relief to an already mortgaged estate, and, though the Season is over, his thoughts turn to securing a suitable wife (and dowry) for his son. The arrival on the London scene of Minnie, a beautiful Chicago heiress with a reputation to mend, seems the answer to all their prayers. (from Amazon)
St. Martin's Press
January 15, 2013; 320 Pages
From the award-winning novelist and writer of Upstairs Downstairs, the launch of a brilliant new trilogy about what life was really like for masters and servants before the world of Downton Abbey.
As the Season of 1899 comes to an end, the world is poised on the brink of profound, irrevocable change. The Earl of Dilberne is facing serious financial concerns. The ripple effects spread to everyone in the household: Lord Robert, who has gambled unwisely on the stock market and seeks a place in the Cabinet; his unmarried children, Arthur, who keeps a courtesan, and Rosina, who keeps a parrot in her bedroom; Lord Robert’s wife Isobel, who orders the affairs of the household in Belgrave Square; and Grace, the lady’s maid who orders the life of her mistress.
Lord Robert can see no financial relief to an already mortgaged estate, and, though the Season is over, his thoughts turn to securing a suitable wife (and dowry) for his son. The arrival on the London scene of Minnie, a beautiful Chicago heiress with a reputation to mend, seems the answer to all their prayers. (from Amazon)
On the author's web site I found this quote, "Books are like other people: some you get on with, some you just don’t. No blame attached." My immediate reaction was Thank Goodness! Why? Because Fay Weldon clearly understands that not all of us are going to love her books. That takes the pressure off. What I mean to say is, as a reviewer from time to time I have to tell someone that I didn't care for their book. That is the case with Habits of the House.
Before we get to that I want to tell you a bit about the author. Prior to picking up this book, I'd never heard of her. Boy was I surprised to discover that she has written more than 30 novels, 7 collections of short stories and 8 works of non-fiction. Wow. Impressive isn't it? It also made me wonder if somehow I had missed the mark on her latest book. Surely as such an accomplished writer she has something that keeps drawing readers in. Plus, in the video that I watched she has books strewn everywhere in her office, has a very comfortable looking country kitchen, and is wearing what appears to be a hand knit sweater and wrist warmers. She clearly looks like someone that I would enjoy visiting with. So what happened?
Habits is touted as being "an entertaining romp for Downton Abbey fans". Am I a fan? Well, honestly I haven't seen it (yet). I know, I heard the collective gasp of astonishment. The thing is I think I'll like it I just don't know when I'll get to see it. My husband has a hard time understanding British accents, so we usually avoid programs where they are prominent. But in my mind I'm a huge fan, and I thought that the book would give me a bit of what I'd been missing. Unfortunately, it didn't.
Here's the basic plot: the family is in financial trouble and their problems will be solved if the son can be married off to a wealthy heiress. A simple story line with plenty of potential. I had high hopes for the family, and for the staff who really keep the house running. Sadly though I never felt drawn into their lives. I'm not sure if it's because I never got to know them very well, or if it's because they're all very shallow and materialistic (even the staff). It seems that most of the book takes place planning meals, dressing for meals, awaiting invitations to meals and eating the meals. I hoped that there might be more action, and was disappointed by the few events that did occur. My favorite characters were Flora the courtesan and Minnie the heiress. Both independent and strong spirited I found them to be the most interesting of the bunch. In fact their actions (aka scandals) provided the topic for many mealtime conversations.
Another reason this book fell short for me is the language. I have a fairly large vocabulary, but there are a lot of phrases and words that I am not familiar with. Normally I don't mind the occasional bit to look up after all, that's how we learn, but to me it seemed excessive. Here are a few I jotted down:
there had to be an end to gadding about;
not to mention her embonpoint;
jingoism, is most distasteful;
having fagged for him;
with greenery-yallery pretensions did not make a grand place;
sepulchre of a subdued house.
I realize that some (maybe all?) of these might be common in the King's English, but for me they're quite foreign. And this is only a small sampling. After page 144 I stopped writing them down/looking them up and did my best to understand them based on context. I also had trouble with some of the menu items, like yellow and green marbled jelly and devils on horseback (which shouldn't be confused with the angels on horseback!).
I wish that I was better able to describe why Habits didn't do it for me. I feel like it had all the pieces, they just never came together. Sometimes that's just the way it goes. Does it mean that I'm going to give up on Downton Abbey? Absolutely not. Like Fay says, "some you get on with, some you just don’t. " Amen to that.
Before we get to that I want to tell you a bit about the author. Prior to picking up this book, I'd never heard of her. Boy was I surprised to discover that she has written more than 30 novels, 7 collections of short stories and 8 works of non-fiction. Wow. Impressive isn't it? It also made me wonder if somehow I had missed the mark on her latest book. Surely as such an accomplished writer she has something that keeps drawing readers in. Plus, in the video that I watched she has books strewn everywhere in her office, has a very comfortable looking country kitchen, and is wearing what appears to be a hand knit sweater and wrist warmers. She clearly looks like someone that I would enjoy visiting with. So what happened?
Habits is touted as being "an entertaining romp for Downton Abbey fans". Am I a fan? Well, honestly I haven't seen it (yet). I know, I heard the collective gasp of astonishment. The thing is I think I'll like it I just don't know when I'll get to see it. My husband has a hard time understanding British accents, so we usually avoid programs where they are prominent. But in my mind I'm a huge fan, and I thought that the book would give me a bit of what I'd been missing. Unfortunately, it didn't.
Here's the basic plot: the family is in financial trouble and their problems will be solved if the son can be married off to a wealthy heiress. A simple story line with plenty of potential. I had high hopes for the family, and for the staff who really keep the house running. Sadly though I never felt drawn into their lives. I'm not sure if it's because I never got to know them very well, or if it's because they're all very shallow and materialistic (even the staff). It seems that most of the book takes place planning meals, dressing for meals, awaiting invitations to meals and eating the meals. I hoped that there might be more action, and was disappointed by the few events that did occur. My favorite characters were Flora the courtesan and Minnie the heiress. Both independent and strong spirited I found them to be the most interesting of the bunch. In fact their actions (aka scandals) provided the topic for many mealtime conversations.
Another reason this book fell short for me is the language. I have a fairly large vocabulary, but there are a lot of phrases and words that I am not familiar with. Normally I don't mind the occasional bit to look up after all, that's how we learn, but to me it seemed excessive. Here are a few I jotted down:
there had to be an end to gadding about;
not to mention her embonpoint;
jingoism, is most distasteful;
having fagged for him;
with greenery-yallery pretensions did not make a grand place;
sepulchre of a subdued house.
I realize that some (maybe all?) of these might be common in the King's English, but for me they're quite foreign. And this is only a small sampling. After page 144 I stopped writing them down/looking them up and did my best to understand them based on context. I also had trouble with some of the menu items, like yellow and green marbled jelly and devils on horseback (which shouldn't be confused with the angels on horseback!).
I wish that I was better able to describe why Habits didn't do it for me. I feel like it had all the pieces, they just never came together. Sometimes that's just the way it goes. Does it mean that I'm going to give up on Downton Abbey? Absolutely not. Like Fay says, "some you get on with, some you just don’t. " Amen to that.
Click on the arrow below to hear Chapter One
Thanks so much for stopping by and sharing part of your day with me.
One of the great things about books is we all respond to them differently. Everyone has an opinion and there is no right or wrong. I'd love to hear what you thought of this book, and invite you to share your views in the comment section.
Wishing you all the happiness words can bring!
Robin B.
Click to:
read more Book Reviews;
go to the Athol Public Library; or
visit Crochet Nirvana!
Win the book and a handmade bookmark!
Don't Go by Lisa Scottoline
St. Martin's Press
April 9, 2013; 384 Pages
From the Publisher:
Bestselling author Lisa Scottoline has thrilled millions with her emotionally-charged novels that feature strong women exploring the boundaries of family, justice, and love. In Don’t Go, she breaks new ground and delivers the story of a soldier who discovers what it means to be a man, a father, and ultimately, a hero.When Dr. Mike Scanlon is called to serve as an army doctor in Afghanistan, he’s acutely aware of the dangers he’ll face and the hardships it will cause his wife Chloe and newborn baby. And deep inside, he doesn’t think of himself as a warrior, but a healer.
However, in an ironic turn of events, as Mike operates on a wounded soldier in a war-torn country, Chloe dies at home in the suburbs, in an apparent household accident. Devastated, he returns home to bury her, only to discover that the life he left behind has fallen apart. His medical practice is in jeopardy, and he is a complete stranger to the only family he has left - his precious baby girl. Worse, he learns a shocking secret that sends him into a downward spiral.
Ultimately, Mike realizes that the most important battle of his life faces him on the home front and he’ll have to put it all on the line to save what’s dearest to him – his family. Gripping, thrilling, and profoundly emotional, Don’t Go is Lisa Scottoline at her finest.
Here's What I Think:
Don't Go should be called Can't Stop. Can't stop reading that is! I read this book in just a few days, and I read Part II in one sitting. I actually didn't move from my dining room table. My husband gave up trying to talk to me because I just waved my hand at him in a sort of flailing motion to indicate I didn't want to be disturbed. Kindly understanding (as this has happened before!) he kept my tea warm and the cookie jar full.
I should begin by telling you that I am a huge fan of Lisa Scottoline's non-fiction humor. I find these books laugh out loud funny. But for some reason, I've only read a few of her non-fiction works. Dirty Blonde was the first and more recently Come Home. I know that I enjoyed both of them so I'm not sure why I haven't read more of her. A case of too many books and too little time I think. So when I received the early reader edition in the mail from St. Martin's I was excited to have a chance to get to know her writing better. I wasn't sure what to expect mainly because I tend to avoid books about soldiers/war/Afghanistan.
This story grabbed me from the very first chapter. I started reading while having lunch and was honestly disappointed when I had to stop because it was time to go to work! So while Mike, the main character, is a doctor on active duty in Afghanistan, this is not (just) a story about war. This is a story about family, loss, love, dedication, conviction, addiction, betrayal, redemption and so much more. It's a bit of a: thriller, mystery, legal drama, war story and romance. It's real and human. The characters are so complete and full. These are people that I know, that you know. People that live in our neighborhood.
Through Lisa's writing I felt their emotions. Their pain, confusion, anger, frustration, fear and relief. Some books will develop the main character who carries everyone else. That's not the case here. All of the people Mike encounters are fully developed. I could easily visualize each of them, and see their behavior. I tried to anticipate what was going to happen next. Who was going to do what and how people would respond. But unexpected things kept happening which surprised me just as much as how the characters were reacting to the different situations! Not knowing kept the pages turning!
I often find in fiction (that is based in reality) the things that happen are just absurd. That's not the case here. In Don't Go the twists and turns are real. They may be things that most of us don't think about every day, but they are certainly things that could occur. I'm sure most of you have experienced something that happened out of the blue that changed your life forever. I know I have.
In addition to the in-depth character development and the intricate, suspenseful story telling, I really liked this book because of the accurate and factual descriptions of the details that create the story.
For example: the medical procedures; the alcohol and prescription drug addiction, and the legal proceedings are written in a way that respects the readers intelligence. This is just a small sample that demonstrates the authors willingness to study and research things (like what life is like for a combat doctor) that provide the rich and vivid images that immerse you in the heart and soul of the story and keep you fully entranced until the last page.
In my opinion it is a terrific effort that will appeal to a wide audience. There's so much that I'd love to tell you about, but I don't want to give anything away! I want you to have the chance to read it, and discover all it has to offer on your own. That's why I'm giving away my advance reader copy! The book goes on sale April 9 and I know that our library already has it on per-order. If your interested in getting your hands on a copy sooner rather than later all you have to do is enter the raffle. It's free and easy and open to everyone in the US. All you need is a valid email address and/or a Facebook account to login to the widget below.
St. Martin's Press
April 9, 2013; 384 Pages
From the Publisher:
Bestselling author Lisa Scottoline has thrilled millions with her emotionally-charged novels that feature strong women exploring the boundaries of family, justice, and love. In Don’t Go, she breaks new ground and delivers the story of a soldier who discovers what it means to be a man, a father, and ultimately, a hero.When Dr. Mike Scanlon is called to serve as an army doctor in Afghanistan, he’s acutely aware of the dangers he’ll face and the hardships it will cause his wife Chloe and newborn baby. And deep inside, he doesn’t think of himself as a warrior, but a healer.
However, in an ironic turn of events, as Mike operates on a wounded soldier in a war-torn country, Chloe dies at home in the suburbs, in an apparent household accident. Devastated, he returns home to bury her, only to discover that the life he left behind has fallen apart. His medical practice is in jeopardy, and he is a complete stranger to the only family he has left - his precious baby girl. Worse, he learns a shocking secret that sends him into a downward spiral.
Ultimately, Mike realizes that the most important battle of his life faces him on the home front and he’ll have to put it all on the line to save what’s dearest to him – his family. Gripping, thrilling, and profoundly emotional, Don’t Go is Lisa Scottoline at her finest.
Here's What I Think:
Don't Go should be called Can't Stop. Can't stop reading that is! I read this book in just a few days, and I read Part II in one sitting. I actually didn't move from my dining room table. My husband gave up trying to talk to me because I just waved my hand at him in a sort of flailing motion to indicate I didn't want to be disturbed. Kindly understanding (as this has happened before!) he kept my tea warm and the cookie jar full.
I should begin by telling you that I am a huge fan of Lisa Scottoline's non-fiction humor. I find these books laugh out loud funny. But for some reason, I've only read a few of her non-fiction works. Dirty Blonde was the first and more recently Come Home. I know that I enjoyed both of them so I'm not sure why I haven't read more of her. A case of too many books and too little time I think. So when I received the early reader edition in the mail from St. Martin's I was excited to have a chance to get to know her writing better. I wasn't sure what to expect mainly because I tend to avoid books about soldiers/war/Afghanistan.
This story grabbed me from the very first chapter. I started reading while having lunch and was honestly disappointed when I had to stop because it was time to go to work! So while Mike, the main character, is a doctor on active duty in Afghanistan, this is not (just) a story about war. This is a story about family, loss, love, dedication, conviction, addiction, betrayal, redemption and so much more. It's a bit of a: thriller, mystery, legal drama, war story and romance. It's real and human. The characters are so complete and full. These are people that I know, that you know. People that live in our neighborhood.
Through Lisa's writing I felt their emotions. Their pain, confusion, anger, frustration, fear and relief. Some books will develop the main character who carries everyone else. That's not the case here. All of the people Mike encounters are fully developed. I could easily visualize each of them, and see their behavior. I tried to anticipate what was going to happen next. Who was going to do what and how people would respond. But unexpected things kept happening which surprised me just as much as how the characters were reacting to the different situations! Not knowing kept the pages turning!
I often find in fiction (that is based in reality) the things that happen are just absurd. That's not the case here. In Don't Go the twists and turns are real. They may be things that most of us don't think about every day, but they are certainly things that could occur. I'm sure most of you have experienced something that happened out of the blue that changed your life forever. I know I have.
In addition to the in-depth character development and the intricate, suspenseful story telling, I really liked this book because of the accurate and factual descriptions of the details that create the story.
For example: the medical procedures; the alcohol and prescription drug addiction, and the legal proceedings are written in a way that respects the readers intelligence. This is just a small sample that demonstrates the authors willingness to study and research things (like what life is like for a combat doctor) that provide the rich and vivid images that immerse you in the heart and soul of the story and keep you fully entranced until the last page.
In my opinion it is a terrific effort that will appeal to a wide audience. There's so much that I'd love to tell you about, but I don't want to give anything away! I want you to have the chance to read it, and discover all it has to offer on your own. That's why I'm giving away my advance reader copy! The book goes on sale April 9 and I know that our library already has it on per-order. If your interested in getting your hands on a copy sooner rather than later all you have to do is enter the raffle. It's free and easy and open to everyone in the US. All you need is a valid email address and/or a Facebook account to login to the widget below.
Here's your chance to win a copy of Lisa's new book.
It's free, easy and open to everyone in the USA!
A few things about the giveaway. First, please know that the that good folks at St. Martin's send me newly published or advance copies of books that they have asked me to review. The opinions that I express are my honest views about the books and are not influenced in anyway by the publisher. They don't pay me or tell me what to say. My compensation is having the chance to read these advance titles and share them with you. Second, I'm sure it says it somewhere, but this giveaway ends on Sunday, March 24, 2013 at midnight. I'll announce the winner within 48 hours. And finally, this giveaway is open to everyone in the USA. If I can mail it to you through the USPS please feel free to enter! Now that we got that out of the way - Good Luck!!
| In this video Lisa tours a local book store and talks about what makes a good novel. | I love Lisa's sense of humor! Listen to this audio clip and see if she makes you laugh too. |
Thanks so much for stopping by and sharing part of your day with me.
Nothing makes me happier than being able to talk about books, except maybe giving them away! I sure hope you take a minute to enter the contest for a chance to win.
Wishing you all the happiness words can bring!
Robin B.
Click to:
read more Book Reviews;
go to the Athol Public Library; or
visit Crochet Nirvana!
Brooklyn by Colm Toibin
March 2, 2010
Scribner; 272 Pages
From the book cover:
“One of the most unforgettable characters in contemporary literature” (Pittsburgh Post-Gazette), Eilis Lacey has come of age in small-town Ireland in the hard years following World War Two. When an Irish priest from Brooklyn offers to sponsor Eilis in America, she decides she must go, leaving her fragile mother and her charismatic sister behind. Eilis finds work in a department store on Fulton Street, and when she least expects it, finds love. Tony, who loves the Dodgers and his big Italian family, slowly wins her over with patient charm. But just as Eilis begins to fall in love, devastating news from Ireland threatens the promise of her future.
From my point of view:
What makes a good book? What is it that appeals to me and makes me want to keep reading late into the night? I'd have to say believable characters, dialog that flows easily and settings that tantalize all of my senses by immersing me in a world beyond my dining room. I venture to say that there are plenty of you out there just like me who look to books as a sense of adventure and escape from everyday.
Colm Toibin's novel Brooklyn (or maybe it's a novella) delivers all of these things and them some. A fantastic accomplishment considering the simplicity of the story. But I suppose that is what sets it apart. It is a story of family and relationships that doesn't rely on bad behavior, bad language and explicit sexual encounters.
Set in the early 1950's young Eilis, who lives in a small town in Ireland with her mother and older sister, is surprised to find herself with the opportunity to travel to America. I feel like the book cover description is misleading. It seemed to me like she was uncertain if she should go and ultimately chose to accept the offer of sponsorship more out of duty and responsibility than because she was anxious to go to America. Also, she was assured of both employment and housing. Given what I came to know about her in the beginning of the book I can't imagine that she would have set off on her own on such a journey without the assurance of a decent job and a safe, appropriate room to rent.
Eilis is a wonderful protagonist. She is innocent and trusting, and while she may also be naive she has an inherent wisdom that allows her to handle potentially challenging situations with a fair amount of confidence. Her sister Rose is a great influence on her and when facing something new she often asks herself, "What would Rose do?" and models her behavior accordingly.
I read a few reviews where readers thought that the story moved too slowly or didn't have enough action. I'm going to disagree. I enjoyed experiencing the trip to America, the job at the department store, living away from home in a boarding house and of course meeting a boy as Eilis did. I think that Mr. Toibin did a great job of capturing her emotions and uncertainties. While I do concede that there isn't a lot of action per say, I don't think the book suffers because of it. This is the story of a young girl becoming a woman. It is a story of family and relationships. It is a simple story that beautifully demonstrates how complicated our feelings are and how our lives are impacted by them.
I'm always drawn to books (and movies) that are set in the 1950s. There's so much about this period that appeals to me. The importance of family, the positive morals possessed by many , the prosperity and security felt as a nation, the abundance of opportunities, and of course the clothes and hair-dos! I was absorbed into the details that defined Eilis' daily life. I could picture every aspect from dinner with the other boarders, to her walk to work, the nylon counter at Bartocci's and her first trip into Manhattan.
When Eilis meets Tony there are no sparks. It's not love at first sight. How unusual! (Honestly, how many books have you read where the main character and her love interest fall head over heals the first time they see each other??) I wasn't sure what to expect which made me want to know what happens even more!. I was captivated as Eilis experienced the emotions, questions, insecurities and delights of a first love.
Some folks may have thought the book had a slow start, but I think most agree that as it neared the conclusion it became impossible to put down. I don't want to give anything away, so I'll leave you with this...
I was charmed by this story. After I finished I found myself thinking about Eilis and they way that things turned out. Which doesn't happen often. Usually I'm onto the next book, sometimes even in the same sitting. This is one that will stay with me.
March 2, 2010
Scribner; 272 Pages
From the book cover:
“One of the most unforgettable characters in contemporary literature” (Pittsburgh Post-Gazette), Eilis Lacey has come of age in small-town Ireland in the hard years following World War Two. When an Irish priest from Brooklyn offers to sponsor Eilis in America, she decides she must go, leaving her fragile mother and her charismatic sister behind. Eilis finds work in a department store on Fulton Street, and when she least expects it, finds love. Tony, who loves the Dodgers and his big Italian family, slowly wins her over with patient charm. But just as Eilis begins to fall in love, devastating news from Ireland threatens the promise of her future.
From my point of view:
What makes a good book? What is it that appeals to me and makes me want to keep reading late into the night? I'd have to say believable characters, dialog that flows easily and settings that tantalize all of my senses by immersing me in a world beyond my dining room. I venture to say that there are plenty of you out there just like me who look to books as a sense of adventure and escape from everyday.
Colm Toibin's novel Brooklyn (or maybe it's a novella) delivers all of these things and them some. A fantastic accomplishment considering the simplicity of the story. But I suppose that is what sets it apart. It is a story of family and relationships that doesn't rely on bad behavior, bad language and explicit sexual encounters.
Set in the early 1950's young Eilis, who lives in a small town in Ireland with her mother and older sister, is surprised to find herself with the opportunity to travel to America. I feel like the book cover description is misleading. It seemed to me like she was uncertain if she should go and ultimately chose to accept the offer of sponsorship more out of duty and responsibility than because she was anxious to go to America. Also, she was assured of both employment and housing. Given what I came to know about her in the beginning of the book I can't imagine that she would have set off on her own on such a journey without the assurance of a decent job and a safe, appropriate room to rent.
Eilis is a wonderful protagonist. She is innocent and trusting, and while she may also be naive she has an inherent wisdom that allows her to handle potentially challenging situations with a fair amount of confidence. Her sister Rose is a great influence on her and when facing something new she often asks herself, "What would Rose do?" and models her behavior accordingly.
I read a few reviews where readers thought that the story moved too slowly or didn't have enough action. I'm going to disagree. I enjoyed experiencing the trip to America, the job at the department store, living away from home in a boarding house and of course meeting a boy as Eilis did. I think that Mr. Toibin did a great job of capturing her emotions and uncertainties. While I do concede that there isn't a lot of action per say, I don't think the book suffers because of it. This is the story of a young girl becoming a woman. It is a story of family and relationships. It is a simple story that beautifully demonstrates how complicated our feelings are and how our lives are impacted by them.
I'm always drawn to books (and movies) that are set in the 1950s. There's so much about this period that appeals to me. The importance of family, the positive morals possessed by many , the prosperity and security felt as a nation, the abundance of opportunities, and of course the clothes and hair-dos! I was absorbed into the details that defined Eilis' daily life. I could picture every aspect from dinner with the other boarders, to her walk to work, the nylon counter at Bartocci's and her first trip into Manhattan.
When Eilis meets Tony there are no sparks. It's not love at first sight. How unusual! (Honestly, how many books have you read where the main character and her love interest fall head over heals the first time they see each other??) I wasn't sure what to expect which made me want to know what happens even more!. I was captivated as Eilis experienced the emotions, questions, insecurities and delights of a first love.
Some folks may have thought the book had a slow start, but I think most agree that as it neared the conclusion it became impossible to put down. I don't want to give anything away, so I'll leave you with this...
I was charmed by this story. After I finished I found myself thinking about Eilis and they way that things turned out. Which doesn't happen often. Usually I'm onto the next book, sometimes even in the same sitting. This is one that will stay with me.
Click on the video to hear the author read a selection from "Brooklyn"
Thanks so much for stopping by and sharing part of your day with me.
One of the great things about books is we all respond to them differently. Everyone has an opinion and there is no right or wrong. I'd love to hear what you thought of this book, and invite you to share your views in the comment section.
Wishing you all the happiness words can bring!
Robin B.
Click to:
read more Book Reviews;
go to the Athol Public Library; or
visit Crochet Nirvana!
One of the great things about books is we all respond to them differently. Everyone has an opinion and there is no right or wrong. I'd love to hear what you thought of this book, and invite you to share your views in the comment section.
Wishing you all the happiness words can bring!
Robin B.
Click to:
read more Book Reviews;
go to the Athol Public Library; or
visit Crochet Nirvana!
|
|
Avis R. is lucky number 12, and she shared her favorite Valentine Story:
"My favorite Valentine story is was actually a movie, Valentine's Day with Ashton Kusher (sic) and others. He played a florist and the movie encompassed just this one day and the scenery, people, all of it was lovely fun, funny and if not touching, felt good."
Thanks so much to all of you who entered and those of you who just stopped by for a visit. I love sharing books with friends! That means that there will be more giveaways happening soon! There's new fiction from best selling authors (like Lisa Scottoline) and some terrific knitting and crochet books for my crafty readers.
Stay tuned. Because what's better than getting (free!) books in mail? (Okay, except maybe (free) yarn if you're a fiber-nut like me!)
"My favorite Valentine story is was actually a movie, Valentine's Day with Ashton Kusher (sic) and others. He played a florist and the movie encompassed just this one day and the scenery, people, all of it was lovely fun, funny and if not touching, felt good."
Thanks so much to all of you who entered and those of you who just stopped by for a visit. I love sharing books with friends! That means that there will be more giveaways happening soon! There's new fiction from best selling authors (like Lisa Scottoline) and some terrific knitting and crochet books for my crafty readers.
Stay tuned. Because what's better than getting (free!) books in mail? (Okay, except maybe (free) yarn if you're a fiber-nut like me!)
Thanks so much for stopping by and sharing part of your day with me.
Wishing you all the happiness words can bring!
Robin B.
The Friday Harbor Series
| 
| 
| 
|
Every so often a series comes along that captures your imagination and makes you feel like you're part of the family. For me, this is one of those series. Each book is unique and entertaining on its own, and together they form the landscape of Friday Harbor, a town kissed by magic. The people who live there have stories that are funny, hopeful, sad, whimsical, mysterious, romantic and dangerous.
Christmas Eve at Friday Harbor is the first book. I only became aware of it this December when I watched the Hallmark movie Christmas with Holly. It didn't take long to figure out the that story was based on characters from Friday Harbor. It's a gentler version of the book with some significant made for TV changes, but that doesn't stop it from being a good addition to ever growing list of holiday movies. In Rainshadow Road Lucy has a deep connection with an antique stained glass window and the unusual power it posses. Her special talent shines in her work as a glass artist producing designs that are truly original. In Dream Lake Zoe's cooking has the ability to do more than just comfort weary souls. I found myself salivating for, "...flavors nudging each other forward in clever ways. Souffles so light they seemed to have been inflated by a wish, and eggs Benedict blanketed with hollandaise the color of sunflowers." Yum!
Ms. Kleypas has a way with words that stimulates your senses and brings the stories to life. One of the reasons that I have enjoyed these books so much is that you never know what direction they will take. The series is centered around 3 brothers and the woman in there lives. There is a continuity in the people and places, but the stories are diverse with surprising subplots that keep you reading way past bed time!
Christmas Eve at Friday Harbor is the first book. I only became aware of it this December when I watched the Hallmark movie Christmas with Holly. It didn't take long to figure out the that story was based on characters from Friday Harbor. It's a gentler version of the book with some significant made for TV changes, but that doesn't stop it from being a good addition to ever growing list of holiday movies. In Rainshadow Road Lucy has a deep connection with an antique stained glass window and the unusual power it posses. Her special talent shines in her work as a glass artist producing designs that are truly original. In Dream Lake Zoe's cooking has the ability to do more than just comfort weary souls. I found myself salivating for, "...flavors nudging each other forward in clever ways. Souffles so light they seemed to have been inflated by a wish, and eggs Benedict blanketed with hollandaise the color of sunflowers." Yum!
Ms. Kleypas has a way with words that stimulates your senses and brings the stories to life. One of the reasons that I have enjoyed these books so much is that you never know what direction they will take. The series is centered around 3 brothers and the woman in there lives. There is a continuity in the people and places, but the stories are diverse with surprising subplots that keep you reading way past bed time!
My visit to Crystal Cove
Crystal Cove by Lisa Kleypas
February 5, 2013
St. Martin's Griffin; 336 Pages
Crystal Cove is Justine's story. She is the owner of the B & B called Artist's Point where she works with her best friend and cousin Zoe. In Dream Lake Justine made a reference to her relationship with magic when she offered to put a curse on Zoe's boyfriend. It turns out that Justine, like her mother, is a hereditary or a natural born witch with magic in her DNA.
Justine has built a good life for herself. After a nomadic childhood, she has a stable home, a prosperous business and terrific friends. Everything that she ever wished for, except true love. No matter how hard she tries, she is incapable of falling in love and finding her soul mate. All because of an enchantment (or is it a curse?) cast by her mother to protect her from the pain of a broken heart.
Jason Black is visiting Friday Harbor on business. An uber rich computer wizard he is dark, demanding, mysterious and used to getting what he wants. He says that he is on the island to finalize a deal for the purchase/construction of a training and retreat facility for his corporation. But he has another project in mind, and this one involves Justine. When these two dynamic personalities get together sparks fly in more ways than one.
Ms. Kleypas has constructed a story that is full of "the good parts"! Her skill as a wordsmith is outstanding and her descriptions have a poetic quality that I find wonderfully evocative. When I read, "The afternoon was deep and full-slip ripe. Dandelion light slanted through the scalded red branches of a single madrone, and gilded the brown tassels of alder catkins." I was transported.
Along with the ability to create breathtaking images she brings romance and passion to this story in a way that makes me feel like I'm reading a (racy) fairy tale for grown ups. There is the right amount of the Prince Charming with a little bit of bad boy and a dash of loveable nerd mixed together together to create the perfect romantic fantasy. The couple's interactions are deliciously spicy and incredibly sensitive. Again her descriptions resonate with images that make me swoon. Who can resist a line like, "I want to talk to you until we've used up all the oxygen in the room."? I should mention that there is a whole lot more than talking going on, and there are several intimate encounters (which is a bit different than the other books).
There is so much more to the story than I can share with you here. As much as I want to talk about it, I don't want to spoil it for you! Crystal Cove is an entertaining read. I really enjoyed the elements of magic and the paranormal that have been part of each book. I think the way that the unexpected is blended together with the "conventional" makes it seem like anything is possible, and who doesn't want to believe in magic? I know I do!
February 5, 2013
St. Martin's Griffin; 336 Pages
Crystal Cove is Justine's story. She is the owner of the B & B called Artist's Point where she works with her best friend and cousin Zoe. In Dream Lake Justine made a reference to her relationship with magic when she offered to put a curse on Zoe's boyfriend. It turns out that Justine, like her mother, is a hereditary or a natural born witch with magic in her DNA.
Justine has built a good life for herself. After a nomadic childhood, she has a stable home, a prosperous business and terrific friends. Everything that she ever wished for, except true love. No matter how hard she tries, she is incapable of falling in love and finding her soul mate. All because of an enchantment (or is it a curse?) cast by her mother to protect her from the pain of a broken heart.
Jason Black is visiting Friday Harbor on business. An uber rich computer wizard he is dark, demanding, mysterious and used to getting what he wants. He says that he is on the island to finalize a deal for the purchase/construction of a training and retreat facility for his corporation. But he has another project in mind, and this one involves Justine. When these two dynamic personalities get together sparks fly in more ways than one.
Ms. Kleypas has constructed a story that is full of "the good parts"! Her skill as a wordsmith is outstanding and her descriptions have a poetic quality that I find wonderfully evocative. When I read, "The afternoon was deep and full-slip ripe. Dandelion light slanted through the scalded red branches of a single madrone, and gilded the brown tassels of alder catkins." I was transported.
Along with the ability to create breathtaking images she brings romance and passion to this story in a way that makes me feel like I'm reading a (racy) fairy tale for grown ups. There is the right amount of the Prince Charming with a little bit of bad boy and a dash of loveable nerd mixed together together to create the perfect romantic fantasy. The couple's interactions are deliciously spicy and incredibly sensitive. Again her descriptions resonate with images that make me swoon. Who can resist a line like, "I want to talk to you until we've used up all the oxygen in the room."? I should mention that there is a whole lot more than talking going on, and there are several intimate encounters (which is a bit different than the other books).
There is so much more to the story than I can share with you here. As much as I want to talk about it, I don't want to spoil it for you! Crystal Cove is an entertaining read. I really enjoyed the elements of magic and the paranormal that have been part of each book. I think the way that the unexpected is blended together with the "conventional" makes it seem like anything is possible, and who doesn't want to believe in magic? I know I do!
Enter to Win your own Advance Reader Copy of Crystal Cove!
Thanks to the generous folks at St.Martin's Press, I'm thrilled to be able to share the love!
Just in time for Valentine's Day,
I'm giving away an advance copy to one lucky winner.
All you have to do to enter is leave a comment answering one of these questions:
Just in time for Valentine's Day,
I'm giving away an advance copy to one lucky winner.
All you have to do to enter is leave a comment answering one of these questions:
- Do you believe in love at first sight?
- What's your most romantic Valentine's story?
- If you could have one magical power, what would it be?
The winner will be randomly selected on Saturday, February 2, 2013.
Good Luck!
Rules and Such
- The contest is open to residents of the USA only (don't worry, there will be international contests soon!).
- The winner will be selected at random from all of the eligible entries on Saturday, February 2, 2013 at 10 AM EST.
- You must answer a question in the comment section of the blog in order to be considered eligible.
- You must provide a valid email address (you'll be prompted by the dialog box when leaving your comment).
- The winner will be contacted by email on 2/2/13, and asked to supply a mailing address. If I don't hear back from the winner by noon EST on Tuesday, 2/5/13 another winner will be chosen.
Thanks so much for stopping by and sharing part of your day with me.
Nothing makes me happier than being able to talk about books, except maybe giving them away! I sure hope you take a minute to enter the contest for a chance to win.
Wishing you all the happiness words can bring!
Robin B.
It started with a Sparkle...
| I believe in fate. I believe in luck. I believe what comes around goes around, and if you send good energy out into the universe it will one day find it's way back to you - often when you're not looking. As you probably know, I love books. They are the building blocks that make up my world, and have been for as long as I can remember. So it only makes sense that would want to share my passion with you. I get to do it everyday I go to work at the library, and when I come home if I'm not working on a crochet project (or writing about one) you can bet your bottom dollar that I am reading a book, listening to a book or writing about a book. |
I have always kept lists of the books I've read (and want to read). When I started Crochet Nirvana I knew that there had to be room for books. I began with the LibraryThing widgets in the sidebar. Then there was a knitting blogger (Ginny at Small Things) who ran a weekly link party where she asked us to share what we were making and what we're reading. Yippee!! Book and yarn lovers! Next came the reviews. I wasn't content to just share the title, I felt the need to tell people what I thought about the books. Not in a super analytical way, or in a snobby way. Just a girl telling some friends what she thought and how the book made her feel. Turns out people were interested, curious to hear more. And so began Robin Reads & Writes. A blog that is still part of the Nirvana family, but is dedicated to my bookish endeavors.
I love having an outlet that lets me capture my true feelings about what I've read and share them with you. Plus it's a great way to keep a record - even though I still have my notebooks. Now here's the part about goodness in the universe. A few months ago I read a fantastic book called How I Came to Sparkle Again by an author named Kaya McLaren. As I was writing my review I watched a few You Tube videos that Kaya made. My favorite is her skiing in the rain with her very rambunctious dog. There was something about the style of her story telling and the genuinely good natured vibe of her videos that made me decide to reach out to her on Facebook. Something I'd never done with any author. It was simple enough, I shared a picture and a link to my review. I thought she might like to know how much I enjoyed her book.
A few days later I got an email from St. Martin's Press. In short, Kaya had shared my review with her publicist and she was wondering if I would be interested in receiving advance copies of new books to read and review on my blog. That's right, St. Martin's the really, really huge publishing house that handles some of the most talented authors in the world got in touch with me! How incredibly awesome is that?! I was flattered, happy, excited, nervous, astounded - well you get the idea! Oh, and of course I said YES!!
I love having an outlet that lets me capture my true feelings about what I've read and share them with you. Plus it's a great way to keep a record - even though I still have my notebooks. Now here's the part about goodness in the universe. A few months ago I read a fantastic book called How I Came to Sparkle Again by an author named Kaya McLaren. As I was writing my review I watched a few You Tube videos that Kaya made. My favorite is her skiing in the rain with her very rambunctious dog. There was something about the style of her story telling and the genuinely good natured vibe of her videos that made me decide to reach out to her on Facebook. Something I'd never done with any author. It was simple enough, I shared a picture and a link to my review. I thought she might like to know how much I enjoyed her book.
A few days later I got an email from St. Martin's Press. In short, Kaya had shared my review with her publicist and she was wondering if I would be interested in receiving advance copies of new books to read and review on my blog. That's right, St. Martin's the really, really huge publishing house that handles some of the most talented authors in the world got in touch with me! How incredibly awesome is that?! I was flattered, happy, excited, nervous, astounded - well you get the idea! Oh, and of course I said YES!!
Here are my first books from St. Martins
I had no idea when I reached out to Kaya that I was in store for anything like this. As a book lover and librarian this is a dream come true. I haven't wasted any time and I got started reading straight away. I'm working on my review format. Mainly because I want to tell you what I think about the books without revealing spoilers. I'm digging a little deeper and hopefully I'll come up with unique and interesting ways to give you a sense of the story and my impression of it without giving away the details.
In addition to the fiction titles, I've been selected to receive craft books - which includes crochet and knitting, sewing, paper crafts and all kinds of other activities. One of the first questions that I asked is if I can give away my copies after I've read and reviewed them. The answer is Yes!! I plan to run giveaways on both blogs just as soon as I get my first reviews under my belt.
In addition to the fiction titles, I've been selected to receive craft books - which includes crochet and knitting, sewing, paper crafts and all kinds of other activities. One of the first questions that I asked is if I can give away my copies after I've read and reviewed them. The answer is Yes!! I plan to run giveaways on both blogs just as soon as I get my first reviews under my belt.
And if that wasn't cool enough
Kaya also introduced me to an author friend of hers name Leslie Lehr. Leslie has a new book coming out soon called What a Mother Knows, and is looking for bloggers to help spread the word. Of course I said I'd be glad to. Leslie's publisher (Sourcebooks) uses a website called NetGalley to make their titles available for early readers/reviewers. I was thrilled to find that in addition to Leslie's book I was able to request titles to review from other publishers. These are e-books, and while I'm not a huge fan of the format I'm willing to give it a go for the chance to preview new books!
| 
|
It's all very thrilling and I feel thankful and blessed that not only do I get to work with books every day at the library, but now they are being sent to my home and publishers and publicists are interested in what I think! When I started Crochet Nirvana less than a year ago I had no idea where it would take me. In such a short time I have come to know people from all over the world. They have been kind, encouraging, funny, and generous. With each week there something new and unexpected happening. I'm learning new things and I'm interacting with people that I never would have meet if I hadn't ventured out into the world wide web. The law of karma tells us that all of our thoughts, words and actions begin a chain of cause and effect, and that we will personally experience the effects of everything we cause. For me I'm certain that this is true.
Thanks so much for stopping by and sharing part of your day with me.
I'm looking forward to discovering new authors, experiencing different genres and broadening my crafting skills. I can't wait to see what wonderful opportunities the new year brings, and most of all I'm thankful that I get to share all of it with you!
Wishing you all the happiness words can bring!
Robin B.
I'm looking forward to discovering new authors, experiencing different genres and broadening my crafting skills. I can't wait to see what wonderful opportunities the new year brings, and most of all I'm thankful that I get to share all of it with you!
Wishing you all the happiness words can bring!
Robin B.
Notorious Nineteen by Janet Evanovich
November 20, 2012
Bantam; 320 Pages
New Jersey bounty hunter Stephanie Plum is certain of three truths: People don’t just vanish into thin air. Never anger old people. And don’t do what Tiki tells you to do.
After a slow summer of chasing low-level skips for her cousin Vinnie’s bail bonds agency, Stephanie Plum finally lands an assignment that could put her checkbook back in the black. Geoffrey Cubbin, facing trial for embezzling millions from Trenton’s premier assisted-living facility, has mysteriously vanished from the hospital after an emergency appendectomy. Now it’s on Stephanie to track down the con man. Unfortunately, Cubbin has disappeared without a trace, a witness, or his money-hungry wife. Rumors are stirring that he must have had help with the daring escape . . . or that maybe he never made it out of his room alive. Since the hospital staff’s lips seem to be tighter than the security, and it’s hard for Stephanie to blend in to assisted living, Stephanie’s Grandma Mazur goes in undercover. But when a second felon goes missing from the same hospital, Stephanie is forced into working side by side with Trenton’s hottest cop, Joe Morelli, in order to crack the case.
The real problem is, no Cubbin also means no way to pay the rent. Desperate for money—or maybe just desperate—Stephanie accepts a secondary job guarding her secretive and mouthwatering mentor Ranger from a deadly Special Forces adversary. While Stephanie is notorious for finding trouble, she may have found a little more than she bargained for this time around. Then again—a little food poisoning, some threatening notes, and a bridesmaid’s dress with an excess of taffeta never killed anyone . . . or did they? If Stephanie Plum wants to bring in a paycheck, she’ll have to remember: No guts, no glory. . . . (from the book jacket)
November 20, 2012
Bantam; 320 Pages
New Jersey bounty hunter Stephanie Plum is certain of three truths: People don’t just vanish into thin air. Never anger old people. And don’t do what Tiki tells you to do.
After a slow summer of chasing low-level skips for her cousin Vinnie’s bail bonds agency, Stephanie Plum finally lands an assignment that could put her checkbook back in the black. Geoffrey Cubbin, facing trial for embezzling millions from Trenton’s premier assisted-living facility, has mysteriously vanished from the hospital after an emergency appendectomy. Now it’s on Stephanie to track down the con man. Unfortunately, Cubbin has disappeared without a trace, a witness, or his money-hungry wife. Rumors are stirring that he must have had help with the daring escape . . . or that maybe he never made it out of his room alive. Since the hospital staff’s lips seem to be tighter than the security, and it’s hard for Stephanie to blend in to assisted living, Stephanie’s Grandma Mazur goes in undercover. But when a second felon goes missing from the same hospital, Stephanie is forced into working side by side with Trenton’s hottest cop, Joe Morelli, in order to crack the case.
The real problem is, no Cubbin also means no way to pay the rent. Desperate for money—or maybe just desperate—Stephanie accepts a secondary job guarding her secretive and mouthwatering mentor Ranger from a deadly Special Forces adversary. While Stephanie is notorious for finding trouble, she may have found a little more than she bargained for this time around. Then again—a little food poisoning, some threatening notes, and a bridesmaid’s dress with an excess of taffeta never killed anyone . . . or did they? If Stephanie Plum wants to bring in a paycheck, she’ll have to remember: No guts, no glory. . . . (from the book jacket)
I've read this book before...
At least that's what my notes say. What I mean is, after so many adventures with Stephanie and the gang the books have become well, familiar. In the case of Notorious Nineteen that isn't necessarily a bad thing as the rest of my notes say things like, "it was a fun and easy" and "I'm glad I decided to give it a chance." It has all the things I know and love about Stephanie plus the right blend of funny characters and wacky hijinks. I got a big kick out of Tiki and the trip with Lula to Atlantic City to catch a skip. I also felt like the story's mystery has a bit more substance than recent offerings.
But for me there is something bigger at hand, and I find myself wondering,
But for me there is something bigger at hand, and I find myself wondering,
is it time for us to say goodbye?
It seems like I've been in this situation a lot recently and I'm not sure what to do. Several of my favorite authors write series that have been going on for years with no apparent end in sight. And I have to ask myself when is the right time to say goodbye?
Let's take Stephanie as an example. I love her! For years her antics have made me laugh out loud. I've looked forward to dinner with her family and found myself torn between Ranger and Morelli. I've gotten to know the people she works with and the people of Trenton. I am concerned that no one ever bats an eye when her car is blown up, and I think the use of a rocket launcher is extreme even in Jersey, but I'm willing to accept it as part of the formula.
With each book I've been content to read what amounts to the same story over and over again. Oh, the names changes and there are always variations in the skips personalities and crimes. Sadly for me it has become predictable and dare I say stagnant. I think around book 10 or 12 I started hoping that something big would happen. Maybe she would travel outside of New Jersey. Maybe there would be a pregnancy or at least a scare. Maybe she would be forced to choose between Ranger and Morelli or maybe there would be a new love interest. The jacket of 18 raised my hopes with talk of a Hawaiian adventure, but instead of setting the book there we were back in Trenton with only a glimpse of what happened on her trip. How much fun and trouble could we have had in a fresh location like Hawaii?!
For quite a while I've been waiting for Stephanie to grow up. But like the kids from Mystery, Inc. in the Scooby Doo cartoons she seems to be trapped in a time warp. That's when it dawned on me. These books really are similar to 1/2 hour shows like The Simpsons, King of the Hill and yes, Scooby-Doo. In each episode the regular cast has an adventure. The same characters show up again and again, no one ever ages, and at the end of the show the mystery, problem or event is neatly wrapped up. At first I was comparing the books to 1/2 hour sitcoms (like Seinfeld, Fraiser or Friends), but I think the cartoons are a better fit because of the aging thing. Now let me say that I love The Simpsons and Scooby-Doo and right now I can't get enough of King of the Hill. But I'm not sure that's what I want from my books. Don't get me wrong, I absolutely love and appreciate "lite" reading and the pleasure I get from a funny story that doesn't require much effort on my part. But my time is valuable and I have to ask myself, do I want to spend the time I set aside for books reading something I've read so many times before? And more importantly do I want to risk ruining the relationship I've enjoyed for so long because I'm jaded by her lack of development?
When I sat down to read 19 I approached it with an open mind and no expectations for changes in the story line. I knew what I was in for and that was ok. Because of this I found that I enjoyed it much more than the last 3 or 4. But that still doesn't make me feel great about it.
So how long does Ms. Evanovich plan on keeping Stephanie around? I have to wonder if she is content to keep writing these books or is she ready to wrap things up and move on? I suppose it might be hard to retire a character who consistently spends several weeks a year at the top of the NY Times best seller list (it's #8 this week), and lets face it is likely the primary source of income.
Personally I am ready to say goodbye. It's time for something new. We've shown it by embracing the Wicked series as well as the light- hearted Love in a Nutshell. I know I'm looking forward to the upcoming The Husband List with Nutshell co-author Dorien Kelly that comes out January 8 much more than #20 in the Plum series.
There are several authors facing this dilemma. Perhaps Ms. Evanovich will take the lead and gracefully end Stephanie's reign as the most beloved bounty hunter ever. And then we can all feel good about the time we spent together!
Let's take Stephanie as an example. I love her! For years her antics have made me laugh out loud. I've looked forward to dinner with her family and found myself torn between Ranger and Morelli. I've gotten to know the people she works with and the people of Trenton. I am concerned that no one ever bats an eye when her car is blown up, and I think the use of a rocket launcher is extreme even in Jersey, but I'm willing to accept it as part of the formula.
With each book I've been content to read what amounts to the same story over and over again. Oh, the names changes and there are always variations in the skips personalities and crimes. Sadly for me it has become predictable and dare I say stagnant. I think around book 10 or 12 I started hoping that something big would happen. Maybe she would travel outside of New Jersey. Maybe there would be a pregnancy or at least a scare. Maybe she would be forced to choose between Ranger and Morelli or maybe there would be a new love interest. The jacket of 18 raised my hopes with talk of a Hawaiian adventure, but instead of setting the book there we were back in Trenton with only a glimpse of what happened on her trip. How much fun and trouble could we have had in a fresh location like Hawaii?!
For quite a while I've been waiting for Stephanie to grow up. But like the kids from Mystery, Inc. in the Scooby Doo cartoons she seems to be trapped in a time warp. That's when it dawned on me. These books really are similar to 1/2 hour shows like The Simpsons, King of the Hill and yes, Scooby-Doo. In each episode the regular cast has an adventure. The same characters show up again and again, no one ever ages, and at the end of the show the mystery, problem or event is neatly wrapped up. At first I was comparing the books to 1/2 hour sitcoms (like Seinfeld, Fraiser or Friends), but I think the cartoons are a better fit because of the aging thing. Now let me say that I love The Simpsons and Scooby-Doo and right now I can't get enough of King of the Hill. But I'm not sure that's what I want from my books. Don't get me wrong, I absolutely love and appreciate "lite" reading and the pleasure I get from a funny story that doesn't require much effort on my part. But my time is valuable and I have to ask myself, do I want to spend the time I set aside for books reading something I've read so many times before? And more importantly do I want to risk ruining the relationship I've enjoyed for so long because I'm jaded by her lack of development?
When I sat down to read 19 I approached it with an open mind and no expectations for changes in the story line. I knew what I was in for and that was ok. Because of this I found that I enjoyed it much more than the last 3 or 4. But that still doesn't make me feel great about it.
So how long does Ms. Evanovich plan on keeping Stephanie around? I have to wonder if she is content to keep writing these books or is she ready to wrap things up and move on? I suppose it might be hard to retire a character who consistently spends several weeks a year at the top of the NY Times best seller list (it's #8 this week), and lets face it is likely the primary source of income.
Personally I am ready to say goodbye. It's time for something new. We've shown it by embracing the Wicked series as well as the light- hearted Love in a Nutshell. I know I'm looking forward to the upcoming The Husband List with Nutshell co-author Dorien Kelly that comes out January 8 much more than #20 in the Plum series.
There are several authors facing this dilemma. Perhaps Ms. Evanovich will take the lead and gracefully end Stephanie's reign as the most beloved bounty hunter ever. And then we can all feel good about the time we spent together!
Promotional Video | An Evening with Janet Evanovich |
Thanks so much for stopping by and sharing part of your day with me.
One of the great things about books is we all respond to them differently. Everyone has an opinion and there is no right or wrong. I'd love to hear what you thought of this book, and invite you to share your views in the comment section.
Wishing you all the happiness words can bring!
Robin B.
One of the great things about books is we all respond to them differently. Everyone has an opinion and there is no right or wrong. I'd love to hear what you thought of this book, and invite you to share your views in the comment section.
Wishing you all the happiness words can bring!
Robin B.
Greetings Friends!
Welcome to
Robin Reads & Writes!
This is the place where I share my book reviews
and love of the printed word with you.
Thanks so much for stopping by and spending a bit of your day with me!
APL Book Club
This Month's Title
My Latest Reads
What did you think of this book? Is there a title you think I should read, or something you'd like me to review?
Go ahead and let me know, I'd love to hear from you!
Go ahead and let me know, I'd love to hear from you!
Come Back Soon!
I publish reviews often. Sign up for my RSS Feed below to make sure you don't miss a thing!
RSS Feed
Just So You Know
All of the opinions expressed here are my own and in no way represent the positions, opinions, feelings, views, or beliefs of the Athol Public Library.
I am not paid to write my reviews. Any mistakes or misrepresentations are my own and are not the responsibility of the library, publisher or anyone else.
I am not paid to write my reviews. Any mistakes or misrepresentations are my own and are not the responsibility of the library, publisher or anyone else.
